Insurance Savings and News You Can Use
Join the Conversation!

Trucking Insurance for Owner-Operators vs. Fleets

Posted by David Ross on Sat, Jan 31, 2026

Call us for the best truck insurance in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Erie, Harrisburg, Allentown, Reading, Lancaster, and anywhere in PA

Insurance is one of the most crucial and often perplexing components of owning a trucking business. Whether you own and drive your own truck or manage a small fleet of trucks, the correct commercial truck insurance will safeguard your business, your equipment, and your long-term success.

Owner-operators and fleets both work in the same profession, but they need different types of insurance. Policies need to be flexible because companies come in various sizes, face different levels of risk, and operate at varying levels of operational complexity. If you know about these distinctions, you can prevent gaps in coverage, keep expenses low, and stay within the law.

Key Differences in Coverage Needs

The main difference between owner-operators and fleets is the size and risk distribution. Owner-operators usually insure only one truck and trailer, and they often drive it themselves. Their risk profile is narrower but more focused; if that truck goes off the road, they lose all their money right away. Because of this, insurance for downtime, physical damage, and work-related accidents is critical.

Fleets, even small ones, are at greater risk. More drivers, vehicles, and routes increase the likelihood of accidents, cargo claims, and liability lawsuits. Fleets also need to consider risks arising from employees, such as workers' compensation and liability for employment practices. Fleets need more complex policies to address more claims and regulatory scrutiny, but they also benefit from spreading risk across many assets.

Another critical difference is how much money you can spend. Fleets can often secure volume-based discounts and personalized insurance plans, while owner-operators typically buy standard policies that are less flexible but easier to manage.

Policy Options for Owner-Operators

Owner-operators usually need a basic set of coverages to stay safe and legal. Primary liability insurance is required and covers damage to other people's property and bodily injury. Collision, theft, fire, and vandalism are all covered by physical damage coverage for the truck and trailer. Cargo insurance is also critical, especially for owner-operators who are driving their own trucks.

More options can significantly lower the risk of losing money. Bobtail insurance, also called non-trucking liability, covers personal use of the truck when it's not being used for work. Many people choose occupational accident insurance over workers' compensation because it costs less and covers medical and disability costs. Owner-operators can also use gap coverage and downtime insurance to help cover loan payments and lost income after an accident.

Choosing the Right Insurance for Small Fleets

Small fleets need to think more carefully about how to get insurance. The basic coverage for a fleet of cars includes liability, physical damage, and cargo. However, policies should be set up to account for the driver's experience, the vehicle's age, and the area where it will be used. Most of the time, workers' compensation is required, and umbrella or excess liability coverage is often suggested to protect against huge claims.

Fleets have to do more risk management. When setting policy prices, insurers may look at safety programs, driver training, telematics, and maintenance records. Even though premiums may be higher overall, well-managed fleets can secure better terms and long-term stability by demonstrating they can control losses effectively.

In both cases, it's essential to work with an insurance company that understands trucking. Getting the right coverage isn't just about meeting the bare minimum; it's also about keeping your business safe as it grows.

Contact Us for the Best Prices on Commercial Truck Insurance!

The independent brokers at American Insuring Group shop the market for the best quality truck insurance rates that match your needs!

Call us today at (610) 775-3848 or online for the best truck and commercial vehicle insurance rates! 

Tags: Commercial Vehicle Insurance, truck insurance, Trucking Insurance